Taste Your Way Through Treasure Island
- July 25, 2025
- Chloe Ketterer
Taste Your Way Through Treasure Island
There’s no better way to experience the laid-back charm of Treasure Island than by eating like a local. From beachy breakfast spots to fresh seafood dinners and sunset cocktails, the island is full of flavors that capture its relaxed, coastal vibe. Whether you’re here for a quick weekend or a longer beach retreat, this food-focused tour will help you explore the best bites just minutes from Crystal Palms Beach Resort.
Start Your Day at Foxy’s Cafe
Kick off your morning with a hearty, casual breakfast at Foxy’s Cafe, a local favorite known for its friendly service and classic comfort food. The kids will love the pancakes, and adults can dig into omelets, breakfast sandwiches, or a strong cup of coffee on the outdoor patio. It’s a low-key, no-frills place that feels like part of the neighborhood. And it’s just a short stroll from the beach. Perfect fuel for a day in the sun.
Grab Lunch at Caddy’s Treasure Island
For lunch with a view, head to Caddy’s on the Beach, where toes-in-the-sand dining meets fresh Florida fare. This beachfront spot serves up tacos, burgers, salads, and seafood in a casual setting with live music and a fun crowd. Try the mahi sandwich or coconut shrimp and grab a cold drink from the bar. There’s often a DJ or acoustic set playing in the background, so the vibe is always upbeat. It’s an ideal stop for a mid-day break without leaving the beach.
Snack and Stroll at John's Pass Village
In the afternoon, make your way to John’s Pass Village, just a quick drive or bike ride from Crystal Palms. While technically in Madeira Beach, it’s close enough to count and packed with local flavor. Browse the shops while snacking on saltwater taffy, fresh fudge, or a scoop of homemade ice cream from one of the local parlors. You can also grab a quick bite at one of the walk-up seafood shacks offering grouper nuggets or smoked fish spread. It’s a great way to snack, explore, and take in the local vibe.
Dinner at Middle Grounds Grill
When it’s time for a proper dinner, make a reservation at Middle Grounds Grill, a polished yet family-friendly restaurant just a short walk from the hotel. The menu features fresh-caught seafood, steaks, and pasta dishes with an upscale twist. Locals rave about the lobster bisque and tuna sashimi. The interior is warm and welcoming, and the service is always top notch. It’s a great spot for a special night out without needing to dress up too much.
End with Drinks at Sunset Beach
Wrap up your flavor tour with a sunset cocktail at Sunset Beach Pavilion or one of the local tiki bars. The relaxed setting and unbeatable views are the perfect backdrop for a tropical drink or a nightcap. If you’re lucky, you might catch live music or a drum circle on the sand. It’s the kind of place where the evening flows slowly and the views steal the show. There’s no better way to close out a day of good food and beach town charm.
Stay at Crystal Palms Beach Resort
Treasure Island’s local flavor is just one of the many reasons to stay at Crystal Palms Beach Resort. With our spacious, condo-style suites and prime location near all the best restaurants, cafes, and beach bars, you can explore the island without going far. Enjoy the comforts of home with the perks of a beach vacation, all just steps from the sand. Ready to taste the best of Treasure Island? Book your stay at Crystal Palms today.