Top 5 Ice Cream Shops in Treasure Island, Florida
- August 11, 2025
- Chloe Ketterer
Top 5 Ice Cream Shops in Treasure Island, Florida
There’s something about salty air, warm sunshine, and the sound of waves that makes a scoop of ice cream taste even better. Whether you’re coming off a long beach day, out for a family stroll, or just craving a little something sweet during your stay in Treasure Island, you’ll be thrilled to know the area is home to several outstanding ice cream shops. From classic soft serve to rich homemade scoops, each spot offers its own unique flavor of local charm.
1. Super Scoops Inc.
Located right along Gulf Boulevard, Super Scoops Inc. is a family-owned favorite that’s won the hearts of locals and tourists alike. This cheerful little spot serves Big Olaf ice cream, made with high butterfat content for extra creamy texture and bold flavor. Their portion sizes are generous, and the staff is always warm and welcoming. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic waffle cone, a towering sundae, or a hand-spun milkshake, Super Scoops delivers every time. Many guests say it’s their first and last stop whenever they’re in town, and it’s not hard to see why once you’ve had a taste.
2. Shake Shop
The Shake Shop is a true old-school treasure that’s been delighting visitors for years with its soft-serve perfection. With a casual walk-up window and views of the beach just across the street, it’s a perfect place to grab a cone and catch the sunset. They specialize in soft-serve classics like chocolate-vanilla twists, root beer floats, and peanut butter malts. The prices are affordable, and the service is quick, making it ideal for families on the go or couples looking for a nostalgic date-night treat. Don’t miss their dipped cones or classic banana splits, they’re local legends.
3. Sweets & Treats
Just a short drive away, Sweets & Treats is a cozy shop that offers small-batch, homemade ice cream in a rotating selection of creative flavors. Think sea salt caramel, blueberry cheesecake, or toasted coconut, depending on the day. The interior has a welcoming, vintage-inspired vibe, and you’ll also find a display of freshly baked cookies, cupcakes, and candy for those with extra-sweet cravings. What sets Sweets & Treats apart is the clear care and quality in every scoop. It’s a great spot to cool off after a warm afternoon of shopping or sightseeing around Treasure Island.
4. Tootsie’s Sugar Shop
Tootsie’s Sugar Shop brings the charm of a classic soda fountain to life, with whimsical décor and a menu full of sweet delights. They offer a wide range of ice cream flavors, sundaes with all the fixings, and old-fashioned sodas made just the way they used to be. Kids love the colorful candy selection, and adults appreciate the throwback atmosphere that blends retro design with family-friendly hospitality. The scoops here are rich and flavorful, with seasonal specialties often making an appearance. Tootsie’s is more than an ice cream stop, it’s an experience that captures the playful spirit of a beachside vacation.
5. P’s Ice Cream Shop
Tucked just off the main road, P’s Ice Cream Shop is a low-key gem that offers big flavor in a relaxed setting. The menu features both traditional and inventive options, and you’ll often find homemade touches that elevate the entire experience. It’s a local go-to for hand-dipped cones, milkshakes, and even non-dairy options for those with dietary preferences. With minimal fuss and maximum flavor, P’s is perfect for anyone looking to escape the crowds and enjoy a peaceful treat. Their customer service is consistently praised, and the atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, just like Treasure Island itself.
Ready for the Sweet Stay?
If you’re planning a visit to Treasure Island, make sure your home base is as perfect as your dessert. At Provident Oceana Beachfront Suites, you’ll enjoy spacious accommodations, stunning views of the Gulf, and easy access to the island’s best attractions (and ice cream shops!) Book your stay today and make your vacation as sweet as it is relaxing.